Understanding Ministers vs State Secretaries in Government
A Public Affairs Puzzle: Who Really Holds the Power?
In the world of public affairs, identifying the right stakeholder is everything. But in European governments, titles can be dangerously misleading. Is a “State Secretary” a junior assistant or a top-tier cabinet member? Knowing the difference is critical to your strategy.
The roles of ministers and state secretaries (or secretaries of state) are crucial. These positions, while similar, differ significantly across countries, shaping how policies are developed and implemented. This post explores their responsibilities, focusing on why the hierarchy changes between countries like the US/UK and Germany/France.
Model 1: The US & UK System (Secretaries as Leaders)
In the US and the UK, the “Secretary of State” is typically a senior cabinet official who heads a government department. Ministers are often their deputies.
- United States: The Secretary of State is a top-tier official heading the State Department (foreign affairs). Other “Secretaries” (e.g., Secretary of Defense, Secretary of the Treasury) are also cabinet-level leaders, senior to any “ministers” or “assistant secretaries.”
- United Kingdom: A Secretary of State (e.g., Home Secretary, Foreign Secretary) is a senior minister in charge of a department. “Ministers of State” are junior to them and handle specific policy areas within the department.
In this model, the “Secretary” is the primary authority, and “Ministers” support them.
Model 2: The German & French System (Secretaries as Deputies)
In contrast, many European countries, including Germany and France, reverse this hierarchy. The “Minister” is the political head, and the “State Secretary” is the high-ranking deputy. This model is also common in countries like Italy, Spain, and Poland.
- Germany: Federal Ministers (Bundesminister) are political appointees and cabinet members. They are supported by State Secretaries (Staatssekretäre), who are top-ranking civil servants responsible for policy implementation and administrative tasks. (Germany also has Parliamentary State Secretaries, who are elected MPs acting as political deputies).
- France: Ministers (Ministres) are at the top, with State Secretaries (Secrétaires d’État) acting as deputies or junior ministers within their ministries.
- Italy, Spain, Poland: These countries typically follow a similar structure where a Minister is the head of a department, and State Secretaries (or equivalent roles like Undersecretaries in Italy/Spain) are senior deputies or junior ministers.
- India & Indonesia: This model is also common globally. In India, “Secretaries” are the highest-ranking civil servants who report to the “Union Ministers” (the political leaders).
Why the Difference? History and Governance
These differences aren’t random; they reflect deep-rooted approaches to governance:
- Historical Evolution: In the UK and US, “Secretaries of State” evolved to be central, powerful figures, emphasizing strong political leadership within departments.
- Civil Service Tradition: Germany, France, Italy, Spain, and Poland have a strong tradition of a professional, career-based civil service. The clear distinction between political appointees (Ministers) and career civil servants (State Secretaries) is designed to ensure stable, professional policy implementation, regardless of which party is in power.
From Information to Intelligence: Tracking All Actors
Understanding these roles is a critical first step. But how do you monitor them all at once? An EU legislative file is discussed by a Minister in France, a Secretary of State in the UK, and a Parliamentary State Secretary in Germany. Manually tracking all these different actors across dozens of national and EU websites is impossible.
This is where Insights by Policy-Insider.AI comes in. We provide the high-level analysis—like this article—to help you make sense of the complex political landscape. We use our powerful AI to scan millions of documents so our experts can bring you the “so what?”.
But when you need to track all these actors yourself, on your specific issues, you need the full Policy-Insider.AI Webapp. Our app allows you to run one keyword search across the EU and key member states, connecting the dots between a German debate and an EU Parliamentary Question.
Book a demo of the Policy-Insider.AI App today to stop tracking titles and start tracking the entire political conversation.
